Illness & Illustration: The Beauty Myths of Tuberculosis & Vampires

WEBVTT

00:00:09.230 --> 00:00:16.730
This is a podcast about One Health the idea that the health of humans, animals, plants and the environment that we all share are intrinsically linked.

00:00:17.219 --> 00:00:20.859
Coming to you from the University of Texas Medical Branch and the Galveston National Laboratory.

00:00:21.440 --> 00:00:22.925
This is Infectious Science.

00:00:22.925 --> 00:00:24.769
Where enthusiasm for science?

00:00:25.370 --> 00:00:26.033
is contagious.

00:00:29.140 --> 00:00:32.670
Welcome to another episode of the Infectious Science podcast.

00:00:32.670 --> 00:00:33.712
I have Christina here.

00:00:33.712 --> 00:00:34.962
Hey, it's me.

00:00:34.962 --> 00:00:35.783
How's it going?

00:00:36.024 --> 00:00:36.686
It's going well.

00:00:36.686 --> 00:00:37.207
It's going well.

00:00:37.207 --> 00:00:45.368
It's been quite the crazy week, I'm not going to lie, but this weekend's coming, we're going to catch up on schoolwork and all things wild.

00:00:45.368 --> 00:00:46.570
Catching up on schoolwork.

00:00:46.570 --> 00:00:50.801
Oh yeah, that's a crazy weekend and hopefully next week will be better.

00:00:50.801 --> 00:00:51.845
So yeah, Alright.

00:00:52.027 --> 00:00:53.470
And then we have Camille Ledoux.

00:00:53.470 --> 00:00:55.002
I just love saying your last name.

00:00:55.463 --> 00:00:56.087
Great isn't it.

00:00:56.087 --> 00:00:59.686
I always had French professors at Cornell and they would start to speak to me in French.

00:00:59.686 --> 00:01:05.072
I was always like oh, bonjour is about the extent of where I can go with that Croissant.

00:01:05.072 --> 00:01:09.322
They're always so disappointed in me.

00:01:09.343 --> 00:01:10.304
Happened more than once.

00:01:10.304 --> 00:01:14.149
You're not from nobility, or what do you say from aristocrats?

00:01:14.149 --> 00:01:15.570
Not that I know, no.

00:01:15.911 --> 00:01:18.975
No, the farm in New York was not your castle.

00:01:20.400 --> 00:01:20.882
No it was not a castle.

00:01:20.882 --> 00:01:25.191
But we're going to be talking about this today because we have some really interesting topics today to talk about.

00:01:25.191 --> 00:01:29.350
The first one is TB and Women's beauty standards.

00:01:29.350 --> 00:01:33.987
Women's beauty standards so there must be some historic component to it, right?

00:01:33.987 --> 00:01:34.489
Heck?

00:01:34.528 --> 00:01:37.986
yeah, nobility there you go, that's all right.

00:01:38.025 --> 00:01:38.346
Dennis.

00:01:38.768 --> 00:01:39.971
You're forgiven, thank you.

00:01:40.620 --> 00:01:46.504
And then we're going to be talking about another word that I can't pronounce Porphyria and vampires.

00:01:46.504 --> 00:01:48.769
Oh wow, excellent, who wants?

00:01:48.769 --> 00:01:49.992
To start yeah, yeah.

00:01:50.719 --> 00:02:03.143
So I think it's interesting that you brought up whether or not was tuberculosis a disease of the aristocracy, and I would say tuberculosis was a disease for everybody and still is a disease for everybody, especially because it thrives in crowded conditions.

00:02:03.143 --> 00:02:18.257
So, particularly if you're thinking of when a lot of the standards around, like women's beauty being influenced by tuberculosis, were forming in like the 17 and 1800s, you can certainly imagine like a crowded city at those times and TB just spreading rapidly.

00:02:18.257 --> 00:02:35.324
So while it was certainly something that could affect your social status if you were wealthier and got it, it's interesting how TB came to be perceived, and so that's what I wanted to get into today on how TB has shaped women's beauty standards and narratives and how that continues into the modern day, which I think is really wild.

00:02:35.324 --> 00:02:40.584
Yeah, so there's a bunch of articles on this, and the first one I wanted to talk about is actually a Smithsonian article.

00:02:40.984 --> 00:02:50.762
It's called how Tuberculosis Shaped Victorian Fashion, and so basically they start off how, in the mid-1800s, tuberculosis had reached really epidemic levels in Europe and in the United States.

00:02:50.762 --> 00:03:12.055
We now know that TB is infectious and damages the lungs, is spread by respiratory droplets, but that wasn't known at that time and especially before we had antibiotics, victims of tuberculosis would slowly waste away and they would become pale, really thin, and then die of what was known at the time as consumption, because they were literally being like consumed by this disease.

00:03:12.055 --> 00:03:26.645
And so what's interesting is that between 1780 and 1850, according to an assistant professor at Furman University there was an increasing set of citation of tuberculosis that becomes entwined with feminine beauty, which I think is really interesting.

00:03:26.645 --> 00:03:34.561
This person, carolyn Day, actually has a book called Consumptive Chic a History of Fashion Beauty and Disease which sounds like a book I need to pick up.

00:03:34.621 --> 00:03:39.171
Personally, I'll add that and let it be my 70th book of the year Are you on 69.

00:03:39.211 --> 00:03:41.100
Now I am on 69 for a year.

00:03:41.121 --> 00:03:43.763
That's my girl, show off, you're just rubbing in it.

00:03:43.763 --> 00:03:44.163
That's my girl.

00:03:44.163 --> 00:03:44.603
Show off, show off.

00:03:44.603 --> 00:03:45.364
You're just rubbing in it.

00:03:45.424 --> 00:03:46.204
No, we're not.

00:03:46.204 --> 00:03:48.765
I'm not Maybe two, but I think this could be really cool.

00:03:48.765 --> 00:03:56.971
So the book is an exploration of how TB impacted early 19th century British fashion and perceptions of beauty, which I think is pretty cool.

00:03:56.971 --> 00:04:06.978
What is interesting, though, is we do have sources from this time period that tell us how TB was perceived and how it started to be entwined with beauty, like this article talks about.

00:04:06.978 --> 00:04:40.564
They say that there's a book from 1909 called Tuberculosis, a Treatise by American Authors on Etiology, pathology, frequency Diagnosis, et cetera, et cetera, and in it they note that and this is a quote a considerable number of patients have, and have had for years previous to their sickness, a, a delicate, transparent skin, as well as fine, silky hair, and they talk about how sparkling or dilated eyes, rosy cheeks, red lips these were all common in tuberculosis patients, and there are characteristics that, if you think about it, are caused by a low-grade fever, which tuberculosis can certainly cause.

00:04:40.564 --> 00:04:42.211
Blush Think about lipstick.

00:04:42.211 --> 00:04:44.221
We still use these things.

00:04:44.802 --> 00:04:47.927
But makeup's been around for a really long time and certainly in England.

00:04:47.927 --> 00:04:51.350
There's a English queen, elizabeth I this was like.

00:04:51.350 --> 00:04:54.915
She was like died in the 1600s, but she had a half inch of makeup on her face when she died.

00:04:54.915 --> 00:04:55.776
So makeup's not amazing?

00:04:55.797 --> 00:04:57.906
Oh, my Atlanta, a half an inch.

00:04:58.639 --> 00:05:00.346
It was her mask of beauty or something.

00:05:00.346 --> 00:05:09.581
Okay, kudos to her something.

00:05:09.581 --> 00:05:10.386
It wouldn't go with the beard.

00:05:10.386 --> 00:05:11.892
But, interestingly enough, tb was not just on women's beauty standards.

00:05:11.892 --> 00:05:13.238
They also, once they realized, like what was causing tuberculosis.

00:05:13.238 --> 00:05:16.648
They thought that men's beards were like breeding ground of the bacteria.

00:05:16.648 --> 00:05:25.048
And so there was, like this whole campaign, not only for like women's beauty fashions but for men, that they were like you shouldn't have like scraggly beards.

00:05:25.560 --> 00:05:27.665
Wow, so that helps establish the clean.

00:05:27.665 --> 00:05:31.074
Clap man is what I'm hearing, maybe Interesting.

00:05:31.360 --> 00:05:32.463
I had two questions.

00:05:32.463 --> 00:05:35.129
You were mentioning some really cool stuff.

00:05:35.129 --> 00:05:40.983
So first of all, what's interesting to me, or it's confusing to me, is you said that people back then didn't know how it was transmitted.

00:05:40.983 --> 00:05:48.831
Right, like we, we you mentioned it's in crowded rooms, so aerosol droplets and stuff like that, and that's why it's transmitted easily.

00:05:48.831 --> 00:05:59.264
But the way TB is portrayed in movies, for example, is always the focus on the blood that you cough up, right, the blood in the sputum that comes out, wouldn't it?

00:05:59.264 --> 00:06:02.552
And I would also assume that you cough more if you have TB.

00:06:02.552 --> 00:06:07.783
Also assume that you cough more if you have TB.

00:06:07.783 --> 00:06:08.084
Wouldn't it be?

00:06:08.084 --> 00:06:08.947
A one plus one equals two calculation.

00:06:08.947 --> 00:06:15.146
If you end up with cough and you end up with coughing up blood that you think that somebody would understand that's the origin of your disease.

00:06:15.627 --> 00:06:24.043
It's interesting yeah, a lot of it was this idea of miasma which is talked about in almost all classes on diseases, and it's this idea of like bad air.

00:06:24.043 --> 00:06:32.831
So maybe I don't know that necessarily they link that with coughing, but the idea that whatever you were inhaling could be dangerous to you was certainly part of it.

00:06:32.831 --> 00:06:37.899
And part of what was prescribed for treatment for tuberculosis for a very long time was go out to the country and get fresh air.

00:06:37.899 --> 00:06:45.014
So I think that it wasn't known for a while and I'll talk about this that it was a bacterium that was causing it.

00:06:45.014 --> 00:06:49.269
It was definitely something that there was this kind of notion that it was in the air.

00:06:50.172 --> 00:06:50.612
Interesting.

00:06:50.612 --> 00:06:58.353
The second question that I wanted to ask you is you mentioned that the red lips, the nice skin or what was the word?

00:06:58.353 --> 00:07:06.041
The porcelain skin or whatever you mentioned it was seen in patients with TB, and it's might be due to low grade fever.

00:07:06.041 --> 00:07:08.067
But isn't that interesting?

00:07:08.067 --> 00:07:12.764
Because, like when you're sick, if you have a fever or something like that, you don't look good, right.

00:07:12.764 --> 00:07:17.821
So why would a low grade fever make you look better?

00:07:17.821 --> 00:07:19.223
Do you know what I mean?

00:07:19.584 --> 00:07:20.507
Yeah, yeah.

00:07:20.507 --> 00:07:28.432
And it's interesting that it became so romanticized, because now we think about it like if you have a fever, you're like sweating, not looking great.

00:07:28.432 --> 00:07:34.579
But I think it was more of this idea that that women became very fragile with it and it became very entwined with that.

00:07:34.579 --> 00:07:44.619
And in fact, the fashion and Professor Day talks about this, where, when they were interviewing her for this article, she talked about how like elements of fashion start to highlight the symptoms of the disease article.

00:07:44.619 --> 00:07:46.949
She talked about how like elements of fashion start to highlight the symptoms of the disease.

00:07:46.949 --> 00:07:53.369
So you start to see really like pointed corsets to emphasize, like very narrow waist, you're very skinny, the disease is consuming you, you're wasting away.

00:07:53.709 --> 00:07:59.552
And she also talks about how middle and upper class women would then start to like emulate this consumptive appearance.

00:07:59.552 --> 00:08:08.668
They would start to wear makeup to lighten their skin and redden their lips and color their cheeks pink and just to give that like consumptive look, which is really wild.

00:08:08.668 --> 00:08:27.771
I also just want to make a note here that this is also very much tied into the history of women's beauty standards, specifically focusing on white women, and that's inherently racist and absolutely something that isn't called out in any of these articles that I read about this, but it's something that I just want to make a note of that TB likely also still has a role in that.

00:08:27.771 --> 00:08:30.665
That, like this idea of like very pale, thin women is what's beautiful.

00:08:30.665 --> 00:08:32.811
It's definitely has those undertones.

00:08:33.030 --> 00:08:46.913
But the reason why you use lipstick and the Sprite Red is it shows that there's more blood flowing through the lips, and that's the purpose of rosy cheeks too, right, you have more blood vessels that are dilated and bringing blood to your cheeks.

00:08:47.760 --> 00:08:57.716
So I wonder if it's just like an innate thing, part of our almost animalistic side that found those qualities or characteristics to be attractive.

00:08:57.716 --> 00:09:00.288
I'm not sure, because I've always wondered.

00:09:00.288 --> 00:09:13.405
So you see these, let's say, greek statues of women, right, or even the depictions of goddesses such as Aphrodite, I always thought, wow, this is beautiful because these women are so much fuller than what we think.

00:09:13.405 --> 00:09:16.193
Yes, I have always thought that.

00:09:16.193 --> 00:09:17.979
I've always been so surprised.

00:09:17.979 --> 00:09:28.846
I'm like Aphrodite is supposed to be the most beautiful creature in the universe, according to the Greeks, and she is this incredibly like full figured woman and I thought that was amazing.

00:09:28.846 --> 00:09:35.434
And it did not make sense to me when I was younger because, like you say, our beauty standards are thin, pale.

00:09:35.434 --> 00:09:37.782
That is the epitome of beauty standards.

00:09:37.782 --> 00:09:49.907
But then you see the epitome of a beauty standard for these ancient cultures and it was someone who was fuller and I always wondered when did that transition into the current beauty standards that we have?

00:09:49.907 --> 00:09:52.570
And I wonder if TB really was a huge transitional point.

00:09:52.750 --> 00:10:03.285
Yeah, Before you get to that, Camille, I would ask you don't you think that culture standards are also shifting, Because back then maybe access to food was not as plentiful as it?

00:10:03.346 --> 00:10:03.907
is now.

00:10:03.988 --> 00:10:12.826
And if you're rich and if you're powerful you have access to a lot of food more food that you need for your energy.

00:10:12.826 --> 00:10:17.943
Than you're powerful, you're attractive right, yeah, you have the means to nourish your body even more than you need.

00:10:18.183 --> 00:10:20.530
I agree, I agree, I think that's very interesting yeah.

00:10:20.730 --> 00:10:29.195
Yeah, and I think, Christina, you're absolutely right in that the beauty standards we see today are one, especially with the level of thinness, they are not attainable by healthy people.

00:10:30.423 --> 00:10:31.126
It's not a reality.

00:10:31.126 --> 00:10:34.109
I'm glad that it's somewhat changing, but still needs a lot of work.

00:10:36.046 --> 00:10:36.828
Slowly changing.

00:10:36.828 --> 00:10:44.048
I certainly cannot say definitively that TV is what brought us into falling in love with thinness, but it's certainly a more recent aspect.

00:10:44.048 --> 00:10:52.418
Right is what brought us into falling in love with thinness, but it's certainly a more recent aspect, right, 1700s, 1800s was a while ago, but certainly much more recent than you know, ancient Greece or something like that.

00:10:52.418 --> 00:10:56.605
And I'll talk a little bit about the modern conclusions we can draw from how TB has shaped modern beauty standards.

00:10:56.605 --> 00:11:03.366
At the end and I think that's a really interesting point to get into but stepping away from just how women looked, tb also influenced how women dressed.

00:11:03.366 --> 00:11:06.370
From just how women looked, tb also influenced how women dressed, which I thought was really interesting.

00:11:06.389 --> 00:11:14.780
So, upon the introduction of germ theory, once we stepped away from this miasma theory, realized it was a bacteria that was causing tuberculosis, preventing it became very important.

00:11:14.780 --> 00:11:16.625
Of course we were like, okay, we can prevent this.

00:11:16.625 --> 00:11:29.780
And these really big public health campaigns targeted women's fashions a lot of times, particularly the fact that women were wearing like these long trailing skirts and they had this idea that you were like sweeping up germs and carrying them into your home.

00:11:29.780 --> 00:11:37.173
They were real, almost like a PSA as part of the public health thing that they were like oh, you're sweeping up germs and you're dragging them into your house.

00:11:37.515 --> 00:11:53.029
And corsets also came under attack because they were like oh, you need to be able to breathe fully yeah, otherwise you're exacerbating tuberculosis, potentially because of the movement of the lungs being so constrained, because you're just like suffocating, which also what's interesting is that this is when health corsets became things.

00:11:53.029 --> 00:11:57.331
They're much more like elasticated instead of boning inside the corset to keep it so much pressure.

00:11:57.331 --> 00:12:00.582
What's interesting is they were like don't wear these long trailing skirts, you're spoofing up germs.

00:12:00.582 --> 00:12:06.830
So you were basically able to have a little bit of a higher hemline to show your ankles.

00:12:06.830 --> 00:12:11.816
I say that I don't truly know if you could show your ankles or not.

00:12:11.816 --> 00:12:12.517
Something like that.

00:12:12.517 --> 00:12:16.703
We're getting close to it, that's for sure.

00:12:16.703 --> 00:12:17.186
We're getting closer.

00:12:17.186 --> 00:12:18.009
But you could suddenly see women's shoes.

00:12:18.009 --> 00:12:19.394
So women's shoes actually became like a thing.

00:12:19.394 --> 00:12:23.804
So the fact that we have this obsession.

00:12:23.924 --> 00:12:26.129
I was about to say so.

00:12:26.129 --> 00:12:29.514
I have tuberculosis to blame for my low bank account.

00:12:29.514 --> 00:12:30.434
Oh goodness.

00:12:30.919 --> 00:12:33.886
See, there you go If you have a shoe shopping addiction.

00:12:33.886 --> 00:12:46.413
It started because we had higher hemlines and tuberculosis, so you weren't sweeping up those germs Darn, which I think is really interesting, because shoe style suddenly became like an important part of a woman's overall look, because you can see them.

00:12:46.413 --> 00:12:49.453
They weren't just covered by like these voluminous skirts.

00:12:49.816 --> 00:12:50.740
That is so interesting.

00:12:50.740 --> 00:12:52.285
I never would have put two and two together.

00:12:52.600 --> 00:13:08.529
Another thing you might find really wild, which I didn't know until I was reading these articles, is that at the same time that this kind of like raising of the hemlines was happening, doctors started prescribing sunbathing as a treatment for tuberculosis, and this has given rise to the modern phenomenon of tanning.

00:13:09.200 --> 00:13:21.528
Interesting to see how it changes from someone who's incredibly pale yes, that is a beauty standard to someone who's like golden tan, and that is now a new beauty standard All from the same disease Really interesting.

00:13:22.081 --> 00:13:36.755
I heard the story and maybe this is multifaceted, but I also heard the story that the very white skin color, the pale skin color, or the porcelain, which was 200, 300, 400 years ago, was associated with aristocrats.

00:13:37.139 --> 00:13:40.009
Yeah, absolutely, because they didn't have to be outside working.

00:13:40.340 --> 00:13:44.211
You're not a redneck because you're in the sun, working in the sun.

00:13:44.340 --> 00:13:49.440
And I think that, too, translates into other cultures, even if they weren't necessarily in touch with each other.

00:13:49.440 --> 00:13:54.172
I know that that was also something that was very predominant in Eastern cultures as well.

00:13:54.172 --> 00:13:58.732
Like the same thing, right the lighter and fairer complected you were.

00:13:58.732 --> 00:14:14.672
That had a huge commentary on your social status as well, so it's interesting to see how skin color this could be a whole podcast in itself, but skin color has so much commentary on someone's social status throughout history, it should be a whole season not only one.

00:14:15.000 --> 00:14:15.360
I agree.

00:14:15.360 --> 00:14:20.684
Yeah, that'd be a really long podcast and with some people that are more qualified than not Absolutely, absolutely yeah.

00:14:21.025 --> 00:14:24.573
Yeah, All very fascinating and interesting things to dive into.

00:14:24.573 --> 00:14:29.226
I also just wanted to touch back on this idea that tuberculosis became romanticized in this way.

00:14:29.226 --> 00:14:30.328
That it was interesting.

00:14:30.328 --> 00:14:38.857
I found this journal article about it actually, which I was like, yeah, someone's written a journal, Like I'm glad that someone has written, like a journal of TB and beauty standards.

00:14:38.977 --> 00:14:40.418
No, it's like a whole journal.

00:14:41.501 --> 00:14:41.903
It was called.

00:14:41.903 --> 00:14:45.773
Even in Death she is Beautiful, confronting Tuberculosis in Art, literature and Medicine.

00:14:46.823 --> 00:14:47.828
And I was like, oh OK.

00:14:50.659 --> 00:14:56.264
So I was reading this morning, and what they were talking about is how upper class women who contracted the disease were then, like, judged according to their attractiveness.

00:14:56.264 --> 00:15:00.583
And it was like a wasting disease, right, tuberculosis, because it was a wasting disease they were like.

00:15:00.583 --> 00:15:05.543
It enhances your, like female, beauty standards if you become incredibly pale and waxy.

00:15:05.543 --> 00:15:06.885
Who wants to be like waxy?

00:15:06.885 --> 00:15:11.292
I feel like people actively avoid that, but I guess that was the thing in Victorian England.

00:15:11.812 --> 00:15:19.626
I literally could not think of anything worse to be caring about while I am wasting away from tuberculosis.

00:15:19.647 --> 00:15:20.710
Do I look waxy enough?

00:15:20.710 --> 00:15:21.491
Do I look waxy?

00:15:21.491 --> 00:15:22.133
Am I waxy?

00:15:22.133 --> 00:15:23.783
It gets better, it gets better.

00:15:23.783 --> 00:15:24.405
You just wait.

00:15:24.405 --> 00:15:26.371
Is it giving bed baths?

00:15:26.371 --> 00:16:02.145
And so I think what's interesting is that in this journal article they say that towards the end of the 18th century, tuberculosis was identified as a disease which promoted beauty in women and conferred beauty upon its sufferer, and so the waif-like consumptive was dramatically pale, very thin, red cheeks, bright eyes of fever, and that it became really fashionable to look that way and that good health was basically ordinary, like you were so earthly if you were in good health, Whereas if you had tuberculosis you were ethereal and you were artistic and there was something about it and it was really wild.

00:16:02.306 --> 00:16:12.803
And what's interesting is that someone did a study of tuberculosis by taking photographic portraits of people with TB and comparing them to like people without TB.

00:16:13.105 --> 00:16:15.009
Did they have those photos in the journal article they?

00:16:15.029 --> 00:16:15.740
did Some of them.

00:16:15.740 --> 00:16:20.702
They were composites, which it was really wild, and of course the ones that they were showing were of women.

00:16:20.702 --> 00:16:24.159
But it was interesting that there was one physician and then one guy who was a sir.

00:16:24.159 --> 00:16:26.121
I don't know if he's a sir, make you a lord.

00:16:26.121 --> 00:16:27.243
I have no idea what this means.

00:16:27.263 --> 00:16:29.485
Back, in the day Knighted, knighted.

00:16:29.565 --> 00:16:30.346
Okay, I don't know.

00:16:30.346 --> 00:16:42.317
So they had this photographic studio at a hospital in London and they took pictures of over 400 people aged 15 to 40, and 442 portraits of TB patients were obtained from three hospitals.

00:16:42.317 --> 00:17:03.506
And then they did another 200 people that also didn't have the disease and they were photographed and the images were grouped together and they basically ended up, I think, with saying this was not conclusive of anything, because for a while I think the belief that was TB was hereditary, which it can look that way, right, because, like, ok, if one person dies all these other people have taken care of them right in their families, they're also likely to come down with it.

00:17:12.539 --> 00:17:17.045
No-transcript a portrait of people with this disease.

00:17:17.405 --> 00:17:18.769
Does it make them more beautiful?

00:17:18.769 --> 00:17:19.571
Let's compare.

00:17:20.661 --> 00:17:21.702
It's wild, it's wild.

00:17:21.722 --> 00:17:22.983
Yeah, this reminds me.

00:17:22.983 --> 00:17:44.767
Just to infuse this with a little bit of pop culture, I have this movie on my Netflix list that I need to watch, and it's supposedly about a guy who goes to Hungary or Romania or something like that and takes pictures of people that contracted 1918 flu and were dying of 1918 flu oh interesting, so I'll let you guys know how the movie is.

00:17:44.859 --> 00:17:46.165
That sounds very interesting.

00:17:46.165 --> 00:17:47.924
Is it based on a true story?

00:17:47.944 --> 00:17:48.425
I think it's a.

00:17:48.425 --> 00:17:49.730
No, it's a horror movie.

00:17:50.962 --> 00:17:52.567
But hey, I like pathogen horror.

00:17:52.567 --> 00:17:58.006
That'd be wild, though, like the 1918 flu that was some rough stuff, I wouldn't be taking photos of the people.

00:17:58.006 --> 00:18:01.688
I would be like this is not a super safe environment for me to be in.

00:18:01.688 --> 00:18:03.853
Wow, absolutely, that's wild.

00:18:03.853 --> 00:18:05.741
So I just I had to add this in Tu.

00:18:05.741 --> 00:18:09.506
I just I had to add this in Tuberculosis was so romanticized it became a pickup line.

00:18:09.506 --> 00:18:12.430
It became a pickup line.

00:18:12.951 --> 00:18:20.320
And I checked multiple sources for this because I was like this can't, this can't be real, no one can be this dramatic.

00:18:20.320 --> 00:18:20.903
This man was this dramatic.

00:18:20.903 --> 00:18:28.911
So if you're ready, romantic poet Lord Byron wanted to die of consumption and he has said to have told a friend how pale I look.

00:18:28.911 --> 00:18:37.153
I should like, I think, to die of consumption because then the woman would all say see that poor Byron, how interesting he looks in dying.

00:18:37.153 --> 00:18:40.506
Wow, can you imagine.

00:18:40.640 --> 00:18:42.106
But why is that a pickup line, though?

00:18:42.461 --> 00:18:44.742
But that is a pickup line he wants women to be like.

00:18:44.742 --> 00:18:49.032
How pale and ethereal and tuberculous he looks, while dying.

00:18:49.319 --> 00:18:50.744
That's a pickup line, wouldn't you say?

00:18:51.066 --> 00:18:51.768
That is good.

00:18:51.807 --> 00:18:57.463
That's something, or at least a desire to like be, like wow, I don't know, I just think that's wild.

00:18:57.865 --> 00:18:58.887
Yeah, that is incredible.

00:18:59.189 --> 00:18:59.549
Anyways.

00:19:00.079 --> 00:19:03.930
And it also shows how superficial humankind has always been.

00:19:03.930 --> 00:19:04.832
I'm not going to.

00:19:05.361 --> 00:19:05.981
You know what I mean.

00:19:05.981 --> 00:19:11.051
He would rather die coughing up blood, just so women would be like how sickly he looks.

00:19:11.112 --> 00:19:14.163
Wow, so sickly, so handsome in his sickness.

00:19:14.785 --> 00:19:15.446
In death.

00:19:15.467 --> 00:19:18.133
Yes, yeah, anyways.

00:19:18.413 --> 00:19:19.977
Romanticizing death.

00:19:19.977 --> 00:19:21.400
Romanticizing death.

00:19:21.619 --> 00:19:22.961
Isn't that an entire?

00:19:22.961 --> 00:19:24.501
You could write a PhD off of that.

00:19:24.501 --> 00:19:25.502
Yeah, that's still a, thing, right, yeah?

00:19:25.522 --> 00:19:25.903
Absolutely Anyways.

00:19:25.923 --> 00:19:26.423
Absolutely.

00:19:26.423 --> 00:19:28.644
That's still a thing, right, yeah, absolutely, anyways.

00:19:28.644 --> 00:19:45.217
So off of this conversation of TB and beauty standards and how beauty standards themselves have evolved throughout time, I'm going to take this in another direction and talk about how the lore of vampires has actually evolved over time, and this is what Dennis was touching on at the beginning.

00:19:45.217 --> 00:19:50.005
My topic of the day is going to be Porphyria and vampires.

00:19:50.005 --> 00:20:11.981
So originally, vampires, from what I could see in my research, can be traced way, way back, and some of the original stories that at least had to do with a character that resembled a vampire, traced back to ancient Greece, with the Empusa, I believe, is how you pronounce it, or even Strix, and that traces all the way back to about 4500 BC, as late as then.

00:20:11.981 --> 00:20:18.502
That's incredibly early that we even began having some lore about some kind of vampirish figure.

00:20:18.803 --> 00:20:19.403
So was it.

00:20:19.403 --> 00:20:27.223
They didn't use the word vampire, but was it a description of a human in the need for blood or the urge to drink blood?

00:20:27.505 --> 00:20:37.980
Yeah, so the Strix character was apparently a bat with a human head that would feed off of the blood of humans, essentially from what I remember Now.

00:20:38.000 --> 00:20:39.547
I have a Halloween costume idea.

00:20:39.819 --> 00:20:42.488
Yeah, I was going to say that is a disturbing image.

00:20:42.488 --> 00:20:53.148
I feel like, yeah, that makes me think of what we do in the shadows oh my God, when they're like trying to turn into a bat, like Guillermo hasn't quite gotten it, and then he's just like bat, but he's like half human and half bat.

00:20:53.148 --> 00:20:58.023
Okay, so good to know that they're actually drawing from real lore for that, if you haven't watched what we do in the shadows.

00:20:58.084 --> 00:20:58.946
Please watch it.

00:20:58.946 --> 00:20:59.528
It's great.

00:20:59.528 --> 00:21:02.287
Please watch it, one of my favorite shows of all time.

00:21:05.726 --> 00:21:06.968
Great vampire comedy.

00:21:07.088 --> 00:21:08.411
Okay, what's, what is it against?

00:21:08.411 --> 00:21:09.854
Tell me what we do in the shadows.

00:21:09.854 --> 00:21:15.244
Okay, there's a movie and there's a TV series.

00:21:15.265 --> 00:21:16.471
We'll be putting this in the show notes with the articles.

00:21:16.471 --> 00:21:16.792
There's a movie.

00:21:16.792 --> 00:21:17.255
That's how it came out.

00:21:17.255 --> 00:21:18.059
It's originally based on a movie.

00:21:18.319 --> 00:21:19.323
Oh my goodness.

00:21:19.323 --> 00:21:23.996
Okay, just know it definitely got the sexual undertones in the show.

00:21:23.996 --> 00:21:28.286
Overtones for our listeners, so be aware of that.

00:21:28.286 --> 00:21:31.794
But it really is a very funny TV show and movie.

00:21:32.000 --> 00:21:34.326
I would assume I haven't seen the movie though, but anyway.

00:21:34.326 --> 00:21:56.472
Going back to vampire lore, so the actual vampire as we know, it didn't really become a thing until about the 18th century, and that's when we started to hear about stories of this figure with the sharp pointed teeth, with full head of hair, pale and nosferatu, yes, nosferatu, and I actually have some notes about sweet nosferatu.

00:21:56.973 --> 00:22:00.404
Okay, is nosferatu a german word it's a german movie, that's for sure.

00:22:00.484 --> 00:22:01.768
Yeah, but it's the latin name.

00:22:01.847 --> 00:22:05.125
Oh, it's a latin name there's a new nosferatu coming out at the end of the year.

00:22:05.125 --> 00:22:07.151
I heard of that it's supposed to be like horror.

00:22:07.151 --> 00:22:10.785
I meant to watch the trailer last night and I got too spooked, so I stopped.

00:22:11.807 --> 00:22:12.288
Who's in it?

00:22:12.288 --> 00:22:13.308
Who's playing Nosferatu?

00:22:13.328 --> 00:22:15.152
I don't know, I didn't get that far.

00:22:15.593 --> 00:22:16.032
Is it like?

00:22:16.032 --> 00:22:16.835
I don't know?

00:22:16.855 --> 00:22:17.315
It was scary.

00:22:19.875 --> 00:22:36.419
So I thought it'd be good to just touch on exactly what Porphyria is and then give examples of vampire descriptions from literature and also from cinema that kind of allow us to compare the actual disease and the disease presentation to this vampire lore.

00:22:36.419 --> 00:22:51.731
So porphyria is actually a disease that is due to a lack of an enzyme in the synthesis of porphyrin 9, which is the protein that combines with iron to form heme.

00:22:51.731 --> 00:22:56.769
And if you don't know what heme is the oxygen carrying molecule within a red blood cell.

00:22:56.769 --> 00:22:59.342
It's really important part of the red blood cell, right?

00:22:59.342 --> 00:23:03.652
And if you don't have porphyrin nine, you will be anemic.

00:23:03.652 --> 00:23:05.582
And what happens when you're anemic?

00:23:05.582 --> 00:23:08.227
You tend to have what's called pallor, right.

00:23:08.227 --> 00:23:09.669
So you have a very distinctive pallor.

00:23:09.669 --> 00:23:13.015
You're very white, You're very pale, you also don't feel good.

00:23:13.015 --> 00:23:14.806
You also really don't feel good.

00:23:14.806 --> 00:23:15.990
Yes, exactly.

00:23:16.160 --> 00:23:22.064
So basically to summarize that you would say you just cannot make Mature red blood cells.

00:23:22.064 --> 00:23:22.826
Red blood cells.

00:23:22.946 --> 00:23:25.001
Yeah, exactly, you can't make them.

00:23:25.001 --> 00:23:25.623
Well, at least.

00:23:25.663 --> 00:23:28.228
It's interesting, though, it is a disease that's compatible with life.

00:23:28.228 --> 00:23:29.530
Like you can live with this.

00:23:30.271 --> 00:23:53.263
These red blood cells produce this immature porphyrin and then they release it and the porphyrin gathers in the skin and what happens is when you come into contact with sunlight, it causes the porphyrin yeah, it causes the porphyrin to release free radicals and that reacts in your body to cause blistering, to cause pain, to cause scaling skin.

00:23:53.263 --> 00:23:54.686
It's really incredible.

00:23:54.686 --> 00:23:58.381
So I wrote down some of the symptoms and I'll list them off.

00:23:58.381 --> 00:24:09.724
So burning pain when exposed to light, sudden painful redness and swelling blisters on the exposed skin and then also, interestingly enough, excess hair growth in those commonly affected areas.

00:24:09.724 --> 00:24:14.490
So when you think about it, it makes sense, right, because your body's trying all it can to hide the skin from the sunlight.

00:24:14.490 --> 00:24:17.368
So it makes sense that you would grow a little bit more hair, right In those areas.

00:24:17.368 --> 00:24:21.066
That's why we have a lot of hair on our heads, right, because our heads are exposed to the most sunlight.

00:24:21.066 --> 00:24:21.708
That's cool.

00:24:21.708 --> 00:24:22.790
I think that's what I've heard.

00:24:24.723 --> 00:24:29.973
I'm not sure that was like one of the evolutionary what's what I think is kind of weirdest, and then totally sidetracking here.

00:24:29.973 --> 00:24:30.494
That's weird.

00:24:30.494 --> 00:24:33.821
I think we're the only mammalian where we have constantly growing hair.

00:24:33.821 --> 00:24:41.845
Right, every other mammal has a certain length and it stops, but like our hair, just keeps growing right, interesting, I didn't think about that.

00:24:42.046 --> 00:24:43.068
I didn't even think about that.

00:24:43.169 --> 00:24:44.983
That's interesting I always thought it was an insulation thing.

00:24:44.983 --> 00:24:46.989
If you're in the colds, then you're.

00:24:47.089 --> 00:24:54.047
You don't lose I think it is also an insulation thing, but I think another All-side purpose yes exactly that's evolution for you, okay.

00:24:54.921 --> 00:24:57.148
So, christina, I just wanted to ask you a question.

00:24:57.148 --> 00:24:59.788
So the substance porphyrin is the name, right.

00:24:59.788 --> 00:25:02.409
So that gets into the skin and stays in the skin.

00:25:02.409 --> 00:25:04.599
Yeah, does it change the color of the skin?

00:25:05.361 --> 00:25:20.723
Not necessarily no, but what it does and what it can do, is actually deposit in the teeth, and so porphyrin in the teeth will give the teeth this like reddish color, okay, and then it also, interestingly enough, causes your teeth to fluoresce under UV light.

00:25:20.723 --> 00:25:22.003
Oh, wow, I didn't know that.

00:25:22.003 --> 00:25:25.906
No-transcript when we read.

00:25:25.906 --> 00:25:29.376
Let's move on to Bram Stoker's Dracula description.

00:25:29.376 --> 00:25:31.752
Right, so this was written in 1897.

00:25:31.752 --> 00:25:33.912
And I'm just going to read a little excerpt that I wrote down.

00:25:34.212 --> 00:25:39.016
So it says the mouth was rather fixed and cruel looking, with peculiarly sharp white teeth.

00:25:39.016 --> 00:25:42.816
The rest of his ears were pale and the tops extremely pointed.

00:25:42.816 --> 00:25:45.753
The general effect was one of extraordinary pallor.

00:25:45.753 --> 00:25:52.453
I had noticed the backs of his hands as they lay on his knees in the firelight and they seemed rather white and fine.

00:25:52.453 --> 00:25:56.740
So that's just a huge emphasis on his pallor, right On the paleness of his skin.

00:25:56.740 --> 00:26:05.765
And actually it was not a thing, at least in Bram Stoker's Dracula, that Dracula himself was affected by the light.

00:26:05.765 --> 00:26:14.734
That did not become a huge thing until Nosferatu came out, and so Nosferatu is what started the idea that vampires would essentially burn in the sun.

00:26:14.734 --> 00:26:28.893
What Bram Stroker's Dracula did instead was become a little bit weaker, so he was basically a regular human in the sun, and that's how he presented himself during the day, but at night he gained this like superhuman strength and became the vampire Dracula.

00:26:29.413 --> 00:26:30.758
The original is really worth reading.

00:26:30.758 --> 00:26:44.238
I really want to read it and it's not as dense as like some books written during that time period where they're like you're looking at the English and you're like, oh, this is like Frankenstein's also worth reading, but it's like in older English and it's very like it's just long exposition.

00:26:44.238 --> 00:26:47.592
It's worth reading, but Dracula is not like that.

00:26:47.592 --> 00:26:48.474
It's really it's good.

00:26:52.865 --> 00:26:53.080
I very.

00:26:53.036 --> 00:26:54.053
For me it's worth reading but Dracula is not like that.

00:26:54.053 --> 00:26:54.224
It's really.

00:26:54.224 --> 00:26:54.355
It's good.

00:26:54.355 --> 00:26:54.530
I really want to read it.

00:26:54.530 --> 00:26:55.719
After reading these excerpts, I thought it was very easy, at least for older books, to follow.

00:26:55.719 --> 00:26:59.676
It won't read like horror to you, though, because if you've seen anything with horror now, it's not scary in any way, but back in the day.

00:27:01.965 --> 00:27:04.328
Just a little bit of pop culture infusion here again.

00:27:04.328 --> 00:27:05.351
Just my opinion.

00:27:05.351 --> 00:27:10.539
Gary Oldman's performance in 1992's Bram Stoker is the best.

00:27:10.599 --> 00:27:13.211
For me the best Dracula ever you don't think it's Bela Lugosi.

00:27:13.765 --> 00:27:16.133
No, yeah, just it's my opinion.

00:27:16.353 --> 00:27:26.007
Okay, okay, I guess you can have that opinion, not like an entire goth culture has been made around Bela Lugosi's dead.

00:27:26.007 --> 00:27:27.410
It's okay, all right.

00:27:27.410 --> 00:27:30.736
All right, moving on so passionate, I see you differently now.

00:27:31.958 --> 00:27:44.984
That's hilarious, but I guess, talking about the blistering skin, going back to Porphyria and the connection to vampires and Nosferatu the main character, which I guess his name was Orlok that movie was created in 1922.

00:27:44.984 --> 00:27:59.641
Yeah, slyden movie right, yes, and the character Orlok in the end ends up burning because he spends the entire evening, essentially in the entire night by the side of this beautiful woman, instead of killing her and drinking her blood.

00:27:59.881 --> 00:28:02.489
Right Did she have TB?

00:28:02.489 --> 00:28:03.854
We'll never know.

00:28:03.854 --> 00:28:04.556
We'll never know.

00:28:05.384 --> 00:28:09.232
Because it was silent and it was probably black and white.

00:28:09.232 --> 00:28:09.954
It was handsy.

00:28:09.954 --> 00:28:11.739
Her reddish lips, yeah, we couldn't say.

00:28:11.739 --> 00:28:23.914
And so that was more of a commentary, apparently, on just the evil that Orlok himself depicted being overcome by innocence and morality.

00:28:23.914 --> 00:28:35.648
That spun future lore, essentially, and crafted this narrative of the vampire then being, incredibly like, averted to sunlight.

00:28:35.648 --> 00:28:39.885
And so that's where we get our modern day vampire that can't go out into the sun.

00:28:39.885 --> 00:28:46.954
I don't know if it's technically our modern day vampire anymore, because I think edward cullen is more the modern day vampire now they're a better modern day vampire.

00:28:46.974 --> 00:29:07.515
Now they're a better modern day vampire, but I would say the classic vampire that we all know, that that really helped shape that character and so we see a lot of those striking similarities between Porphyria and the incredibly delicate aversion to sun that those patients have with the depiction of the classic vampire that we all know.

00:29:07.895 --> 00:29:09.619
Yeah, very cool, very cool.

00:29:09.619 --> 00:29:14.392
Yeah, when did the whole bat situation evolve?

00:29:14.392 --> 00:29:18.886
Because there are bats that drink blood, but it's just a few species, right?

00:29:18.906 --> 00:29:21.239
Yeah, I have always wondered about their microbiomes.

00:29:21.239 --> 00:29:22.223
What is their microbiome?

00:29:22.223 --> 00:29:23.508
Like that they can break down blood.

00:29:23.508 --> 00:29:25.994
Like the microbiome of a leech or a vampire bat?

00:29:25.994 --> 00:29:27.126
Like that they can break down blood.

00:29:27.126 --> 00:29:32.651
It must be, I feel like it must be so unique compared to animals that are just eating like plants or like meat or something.

00:29:32.865 --> 00:29:33.930
Yeah, or it's ticks.

00:29:34.131 --> 00:29:34.392
Yeah.

00:29:36.645 --> 00:29:44.788
That's so interesting because our body, our bodies, we eat food right and we break food down for its biomolecular components that we need.

00:29:44.788 --> 00:29:45.571
You know what I mean.

00:29:45.571 --> 00:29:50.778
But bats and these animals that just drink the blood directly, like they are getting those nutrients.

00:29:50.778 --> 00:29:54.089
They don't have to really like break down anything, they just have to absorb.

00:29:54.089 --> 00:29:56.369
When you think about it, that's so interesting to me.

00:29:56.369 --> 00:30:01.256
Or at least they break down a lot less than what other animals and mammals have to break down.

00:30:01.256 --> 00:30:02.439
That's very interesting.

00:30:02.439 --> 00:30:04.128
That's something to look into.

00:30:04.128 --> 00:30:05.432
Good point, Camille.

00:30:05.432 --> 00:30:06.615
I've always been curious.

00:30:07.277 --> 00:30:07.537
Yeah.

00:30:07.537 --> 00:30:11.728
There's not that many animals that that do that?

00:30:11.728 --> 00:30:26.217
That's true, yeah, and if you see, what I always thought was really curious, the the bats that drink blood where they they have to land right and then they bite cows or something like that and they lick it up yeah, and they lick it up and they're put in a very vulnerable state on the ground right.

00:30:26.518 --> 00:30:35.576
they're obviously much better in in air or in an arboreal setting, and so they put themselves in this very vulnerable situation to access the blood.

00:30:35.576 --> 00:30:37.027
I thought it was always very curious.

00:30:37.248 --> 00:30:41.527
So they don't actually suck the blood, they just bite blood comes out and they lick it up.

00:30:41.948 --> 00:30:44.536
Wow, I did not know that they're not like mosquitoes or something.

00:30:45.144 --> 00:30:46.730
Interesting Huh.

00:30:46.730 --> 00:30:48.414
You'll learn something new every day.

00:30:48.704 --> 00:30:53.355
And correct me if I'm wrong, but I think they also have something in their saliva that makes the bite less.

00:30:53.355 --> 00:30:56.690
Like an anticoagulant, yeah, and numbs the bite side.

00:30:56.690 --> 00:30:58.574
I think I could be wrong, I don't know, I'm not sure.

00:30:58.574 --> 00:31:02.093
Interesting, wow, so cool, it's very cool.

00:31:02.093 --> 00:31:09.939
So are we going to find all the articles and all that stuff that you guys referenced in the show notes, or can you put them in the show notes, sure?

00:31:10.279 --> 00:31:16.029
Mine's really just going to be Dracula, the book by Bram Stoker, but I'll put a link there for sure.

00:31:16.029 --> 00:31:17.374
Yeah, because it's worth reading.

00:31:17.394 --> 00:31:18.375
It really is.

00:31:18.375 --> 00:31:18.938
What about you?

00:31:18.938 --> 00:31:21.092
Is your source for the Greek stuff?

00:31:21.492 --> 00:31:21.913
I'll put some.

00:31:21.913 --> 00:31:27.134
Yeah, I think one of them was a Smithsonian article, I believe, so I will definitely link that as well.

00:31:27.334 --> 00:31:29.838
Yeah, I have a couple of links to add, but there you have it.

00:31:30.199 --> 00:31:36.088
Yeah, pop culture references too that have to do with beauty standards, and then, or who's the best Dracula.

00:31:36.088 --> 00:31:51.476
I love it, but I hope that everyone enjoyed this kind of section of the podcast that we did on folklore and its connection to science and the world around us, because I thought it was fascinating to learn about these different connections for sure.

00:31:51.724 --> 00:32:02.231
Yeah, if you liked it, just let us know, drop us a line or send us a message and let us know if you want to hear more about Dracula and beauty standards and TB.

00:32:02.231 --> 00:32:04.655
And yeah, all right, thanks, guys.

00:32:05.136 --> 00:32:05.958
Thanks for listening.

00:32:05.958 --> 00:32:06.940
Thanks for listening.

00:32:06.940 --> 00:32:09.153
Let us know what you want to hear in the comments.

00:32:10.105 --> 00:32:10.615
Thanks for listening.

00:32:10.615 --> 00:32:10.989
Thanks for listening.

00:32:10.989 --> 00:32:11.580
Let us know what you want to hear in the comments.

00:32:11.580 --> 00:32:12.701
Thanks for listening to the Infectious Science podcast.

00:32:12.701 --> 00:32:20.714
Be sure to hit subscribe and visit infectiousscienceorg to join the conversation, access the show notes and to sign up for our newsletter and receive our free materials.

00:32:21.247 --> 00:32:29.455
If you enjoyed this new episode of Infectious Science, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and go ahead and share this episode with some of your friends.

00:32:31.724 --> 00:32:34.595
Also, don't hesitate to ask questions and tell us what topics you'd like us to cover for future episodes.

00:32:34.595 --> 00:32:38.932
To get in touch, drop a line in the comments section or send us a message on social media.

00:32:39.265 --> 00:32:44.926
So we'll see you next time for a new episode, and in the meantime, stay happy stay healthy, stay interested.

00:32:44.926 --> 00:32:55.240
Thank you.